Photo: Joakim Kingstrom on Unsplash.

The Persistent is available as a newsletter. 
Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox.

Four years ago, I came across a piece of research that both shocked me and made so much sense.

It was an annual index measuring attitudes towards gender equality in leadership. Researchers had asked men and women whether they thought men, women or both were better suited to leadership positions across 23 different sectors, from politics and finance to healthcare and education. The more respondents who considered both genders equally suited, the higher the score on a scale of zero to 100, with 100 representing a world in which everyone regarded women and men as equally suited to leadership.

The findings were dispiriting. Not only were we a long way from that ideal, but attitudes appeared to be moving in the wrong direction.

This was 2022. A backlash against gender equality was gathering momentum, and in reporting on the findings, I learned that several forces might be contributing to the divide. Some academics I spoke with suggested that the Covid-19 pandemic had reinforced traditional ideas about women's roles in society, potentially making bias against female leaders more socially acceptable. 

Others pointed to our tendency to favor the familiar — a phenomenon psychologists call the “mere-exposure effect,” or “familiarity principle” — which might become particularly pronounced during periods of crisis and uncertainty. With Covid still very much top of mind, there was plenty of uncertainty to go around. The global economy was on shaky ground, Russia had launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, and geopolitical tensions were rising. Whatever the explanation, the divide between how women were perceived versus how men were perceived was considerable. And in the years that followed, the picture only grew more troubling. The Reykjavík Index for Leadership — which surveys at least 1,000 adults in each country covered — fell in 2023, then again in 2024 and 2025.

It did so as a political war over diversity, equity and inclusion raged in the U.S. — then spilled over America’s borders to other countries, too. Meanwhile, threats to reproductive rights intensified; the manosphere gained traction; and humanitarian crises around the world continued to disproportionately burden women. Of course the index couldn't tell us exactly whether these particular developments were responsible for the deterioration in attitudes toward women in leadership, but it was hard not to see the findings as part of a broader pattern.

Perhaps that’s why ahead of the release of this year's index, I found myself anticipating yet another decline. How much lower would we sink? How bad would the slide be? Instead, this week, we got something that was, if not exactly encouraging, then at least not entirely depressing.

In 2026, across the G7 (Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the U.K. and the U.S.) the index climbed one point from 68 to 69. Yes, that might seem like little more than a marginal tweak. And yes, it’s below the 72 recorded when the index was launched in 2018. But it’s nonetheless a rise. And the first since 2019, at that.

Could this signal something more promising? Could it indicate that the backlash against women in positions of power is finally starting to lose steam?

Journalism is under threat.
Please support The Persistent with a one-time contribution, so we can keep women in the spotlight.
Other amount
Join 4 readers who have tipped
A Complicated Picture

The first thing worth considering is that the overall score masks significant differences across different countries. Across the G7, Japan recorded the biggest improvement, with its score rising six points to 76, while the U.S., Germany and the U.K. made gains of between two and four points. But the score fell by one point in both Canada and France. In Italy it remained unchanged.

Even in countries in which the picture seems to have brightened, optimism should be heavily qualified. For one thing, the research showed that younger adults — ironically, people who are most likely to have grown up seeing women in positions of power — remained considerably less likely than their older counterparts to regard women and men as equally suited to leadership. Indeed, across the G7, those aged 18 to 34 recorded an index score of 65, compared with those aged 55 to 65 who recorded an index score of 74. That's a nine-point gap — three times as wide as in 2018 — and it echoes findings from other recent research suggesting that younger generations aren't necessarily more progressive when it comes to gender equality.

An analysis of European Social Survey data published in July, for example, found that Gen Z men — born roughly between 1997 and 2012 — were significantly less supportive of women in leadership than Millennial men, the cohort who are in their thirties and early forties. Last year, research by Ipsos and King's College London found that young men and women were more divided on questions of gender equality than any other generation surveyed.

Something that’s particularly perplexing about the Reykjavik Index though: among younger men, scores improved in five of the seven G7 countries, but among younger women, they declined in four. 

It might be tempting to interpret these particular findings as evidence of a widening ideological gulf between young men and women. But as always, it’s not that simple. 

Setting aside political leadership for a moment, it’s worth noting the index, which is published by the Reykjavík Global Foundation — an Icelandic nonprofit — and the research group Verian, doesn't just ask whether women are equally capable of running companies. It asks whether women and men are equally capable of running companies across 23 sectors, from finance and technology to childcare and fashion.

Of course, gender stereotypes cut both ways. A lower score doesn't necessarily mean someone believes women are broadly less capable than men. It might mean that respondents believe men are less suited to leading certain industries. And it might say a lot about how many industries are perceived as more of a man’s domain. 

Case in point: Across the G7, childcare remained the sector in which respondents were least likely to regard women and men as equally suited to leadership. Traditionally male-dominated industries — including defence, policing and automotive manufacturing — continued to attract assumptions about men's greater suitability.

Is It Progress?

So where does all of this leave us?

Rather than dwelling on whether this year’s increase marks a genuine improvement or merely a temporary blip, perhaps we should pay closer attention to what the findings reveal about attitudes that persist.

For one thing, they reveal that we’re still remarkably attached to the idea that some jobs are naturally better suited to men and others to women. For another, the assumption that younger generations will inevitably be more progressive than their predecessors looks very, very shaky.

If anything, the findings offer a reminder that progress isn't linear, and that we should be wary of assuming that younger generations will automatically inherit more enlightened attitudes than those who came before them.

And while the numbers this year look better than last year, let’s not confuse a pause in the backlash with progress towards equality. Eight years after the index was launched, we're still three points below where we started.

—
Josie Cox is a journalist, author, broadcaster and public speaker. Her book, “WOMEN MONEY POWER: The Rise and Fall of Economic Equality,” was released in 2024.

❝

Note: As a Bookshop.org affiliate, The Persistent will earn a small commission if you buy a book through a link on this page. Thanks for supporting independent bookstores! 📚