Artwork by Queenbe Monyei.

The Persistent is available as a newsletter. 
Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox.

In 2005 during my first semester of graduate school, I wrote a personal essay in which I, the protagonist, had my heart broken. When it was my turn to be critiqued, the professor opened the conversation by asking me in front of the entire class if I thought I was beautiful. I was dumbstruck. Was he trying to humiliate me? If that was his goal, he succeeded. His question said: Look at yourself. It said, You are not a serious writer.

For 12 years, I kept to myself the way my face had burned as I tried to come up with an answer for this man, easily 30 years my senior, while my peers looked on, presumably deciding whether or not they considered me beautiful. I eventually landed on ‘yes,’ knowing that to say no would be worse, weaker. Of course, neither answer represented the whole truth. 

It wasn’t until the fall of 2017 that I openly shared this indignity with the five women who comprised my reading club. That’s when it dawned on me that mortification was the wrong emotion. What I should have felt was mad.

The women in the club, myself included, were all new mothers, clinging to careers while changing diapers, none of us with the time to read an entire book. So instead of forming a traditional book club, we opted to read longform nonfiction instead. The night of my divulgence, we had met to discuss The New Yorker writer Jia Tolentino’s profile of Gloria Allred, the lawyer who represented Bill Cosby’s accusers. The piece had been presciently published less than three weeks before Harvey Weinstein was outed as a rapist, and the #MeToo movement went viral. 

Around a dining table scattered with drained wine glasses, we five women tried to make sense of #MeToo. We wanted to figure out if we belonged to the movement, and more importantly, if it could belong to us. None of us were sure.

As we began to share our stories, using the article as a springboard, an answer began to take shape. 

One of us had been groped at work; another had been sexually harassed by a donor at her nonprofit, and later, stalked by a college professor. As we spoke, with the group as our sounding board, something shifted: We began to believe our own experiences; we began to see how they were unacceptable.

Herein lies the power of women reading together. However charged the topic, book clubs offer a space to be (mostly) unfiltered, without fear of reprisals. And, as happened in our group, the book club can also act as a powder keg.  

With loneliness at epidemic proportions, not to mention plummeting rates of reading among young people and our world divided, it strikes me that perhaps the humble book club could serve as an antidote.

Women are here for it. Though only 7% of Americans report being members of book clubs, women are twice as likely as men to belong to one. Indeed, from the very beginning, book clubs were born out of women’s fury over the patriarchy’s persistent attempts to silence them. 

Journalism is under threat.
Please support The Persistent with a one-time contribution, so we can keep women in the spotlight.
Other amount
Join 5 readers who have tipped
Behind a Curtain

Early evidence of reading clubs in America dates back to 1634, when, in Puritan Massachusetts, Anne Hutchinson, a minister’s daughter who was raised on scripture, was forbidden from interpreting the Bible because she was a woman. Hutchinson protested by hosting a Bible study in her home. At first, the group was composed mostly of women she knew from her midwifery practice, but the numbers grew, and eventually, men began attending, too. When word spread of her rebellion, Hutchinson was charged with sedition and banished, along with her 11 children, from the colony. (Her husband supported her by following.)

A century later, women in mid 1700s England were not only kept out of academic institutions, but were also advised to actively hide their intellect. In an essay originally meant as advice for his daughters, the noted physician, scholar and moral philosopher Dr. John Gregory wrote: “[I]f you happen to have any learning, keep it a profound secret, especially from men.” After Gregory died, his son published the work in 1774 under the title “A Father’s Legacy to His Daughters.” It went on to become a bestseller.

As a rebuke to ideas like Dr. Gregory’s, a handful of radical women — including the fashionable London hostess and literary critic Elizabeth Montagu — began holding co-ed literary salons in their homes to discuss literature, culture and politics. Dubbed the Bluestockings for the casual stockings worn by Benjamin Stillingfleet, one of the first attendees, Montagu invited contemporary intellectuals including the artist Frances Reynolds and her better-known brother Joshua, along with the poet Lord Byron and the noted critic and lexicographer Samuel Johnson.

A few decades later, over in post-Civil War America, the journalist Jane Cunningham Croly, a member of the New York Press Club, founded a women-only club — Sorosis (from sister) — after she and her female colleagues were barred from attending a banquet in honor of Charles Dickens. (The men ultimately relented but only if the women remained hidden behind a curtain. Not surprisingly, Croly said “no thanks” to that!)

The club’s first meeting was held at the famed Delmonico’s, the same New York restaurant where the New York Press Club had hosted Dickens. “We will give a banquet to ourselves, make all the speeches ourselves, and not invite a single man,” she said.

It was Croly’s idea that sparked the formation of women’s-only literary clubs across America, an escape from the endless cycle of child-rearing, housekeeping and husband-tending in a world where women were not encouraged to pursue higher education, much less to have political opinions, or to vote.

“The women who founded literary clubs were aflame with the then-revolutionary desire for education and self-development,” writes Elizabeth Long in “Book Clubs: Women and the Uses of Reading in Everyday Life.” “This was an exhilarating challenge to the norms of altruistic service that had underwritten earlier 19th century women’s associations.”   

Meanwhile, in segregated America, Black women were forming their own clubs, including Pittsburgh’s Aurora Reading Club, founded by Rachel Lovett Jones in 1894 and which is still active today. The women held poetry readings, talked about books and also discussed gaining the vote, challenging racial injustice and demanding equal rights.

”Many of the women were born before slavery, they weren’t necessarily college educated, and there were lots of restrictions in terms of African Americans being able to say ‘OK, let’s just meet at a hotel,’” says Pamela Golden, a fourth-generation member of Aurora. “We have a lot of people who were breaking gender and racial barriers, civic leaders, and they were leading organizations.” 

Many men, feeling threatened by burgeoning women’s literary clubs, forced their wives to drop out lest the reading impinge on their domestic duties. “I have an utter aversion to blue-stockings,” wrote the noted British essayist William Hazlitt in Table-Talk: Essays on Men and Manners. “I do not care a fig for any woman that knows even what an author means.”

But there was no stopping the expansion of knowledge and women’s newfound confidence. Women in these same literary clubs — white and Black alike — sowed some of the seeds that led to the suffrage movement. The reading, the conversation, and the support gave women the strength to initiate political protests and movements. They still do. 

Gaining an Outline and a Shape 

“Women have to fight so hard to make spaces for themselves,” says Dagmara Dominczyk, a Polish-American actor and writer who starred in the series “Succession.” She co-hosted a book club podcast with the novelist Alice Elliott Dark at the New Jersey bookstore Watchung Booksellers, in my hometown. “I love any space dedicated to women sitting around talking and thinking,” Dominczyk told me.

In the mid 1990s, Azar Nafisi, a former professor of literature at the University of Tehran, hosted a secret book club for her female students, an experience she details in her best-selling memoir “Reading Lolita in Tehran,” which was adapted into a film in 2024. 

At the time of the book’s telling, had any of these women been caught meeting in secret and reading Western texts, they could have been beaten or imprisoned. But for those who risked showing up, being in Nafisi’s apartment, with hijabs off and hair out, discussing “Lolita” and “Pride and Prejudice” felt life-changing. Nafisi writes, “When my students came into that room, they took off more than their scarves and robes. Gradually, each one gained an outline and a shape, becoming her own inimitable self.”

Even today, the fight for spaces for women to talk and be heard rages on, despite there being more options for reading-in-company than ever before. There’s the Lavender Literary Society which hosts LGBTQ+-themed book clubs, including for teens. The Bad Bitch Book Club is an online group that prioritizes women and writers of color with chapters in every state. There’s even the free-form Silent Book Club, with no assigned book, no mandatory discussion, but simply a call for people to get together in bars and cafes and read silently. Says co-founder Guinevere de la Mare, “When people are reading the same book, that becomes a point of connection.”

Of her own book club, which has been going since 2003, the novelist and short story writer Alice Elliott Dark, says she appreciates how, after years of reading and talking together, no conversation is off the table. “Discussions that would have been difficult — say about Israel and Gaza — have become much easier because we trust each other,” Dark says.

When I started texting with my own reading club again, our messages easily transitioned from recalling our discussions about Weinstein and #MeToo to the latest outrages –  the Cornell assault and Russell Brand.   

“I wish we could have this conversation in person,” texted one member.

I did, too. Except, because our group has a long history of talking through knotty ideas, we found that we were able to discuss this newest injustice in shorthand, over text, and actually get somewhere.

“I don’t think men have these kinds of spaces, particularly with other men, where it’s OK to talk about emotions or make mistakes,” one woman wrote. “Like they’re in their own patriarchal box.”

“So where do they go without a forum and discussion? Maybe nowhere,” wrote another.

“Like where’s their book club?!” asked the first.

I say, that’s for them to figure out. Meanwhile, we women will be sitting around dining tables, across continents, talking and talking, firing one another up for action.

—
Katherine Dykstra is the author of “What Happened to Paula: An Unsolved Death and the Danger of American Girlhood.” Her essays have been published in The New York Times Book Review, The Washington Post, The Boston Globe, and Poets and Writers. 💛 Queenbe Monyei is an illustrator and author whose work has worked in HarperCollins, in The Washington Post and Warby Parker. She is the author of ABC Black History and Me. Find her at @queenbemonyei.

❝

Note: As a Bookshop.org affiliate, The Persistent will earn a small commission if you buy a book through a link on this page. Thanks for supporting independent bookstores! 📚