Former Costa Rican president Rebeca Grynspan is the front-runner | Photo: Getty Images

The Persistent is available as a newsletter. 
Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox.

The biggest job in global diplomacy is up for grabs — and this time, it might actually go to a woman.

Members of the United Nations are attempting to select a new secretary general to take over from the present incumbent, António Guterres, when he steps down at the end of December after 10 years at the helm. The organization — formed more than 80 years ago at the end of World War II with the aim of preventing another global conflict — has had nine leaders so far, all of them men. Now, the pressure is on to finally elect a woman as the next secretary general.  

Whoever gets the role will take over at arguably the most challenging time in the organization’s history. The United States, historically the U.N.’s biggest funder, has slashed its aid spending under Donald Trump. The U.S. president has made clear his contempt for the organization, using his speech at September's U.N. General Assembly in New York to threaten to “annihilate” Iran and tout other acts of aggression He managed to repudiate both multilateralism and the pursuit of peace – two core tenets of the U.N. system.

The U.S. cuts, combined with funding reductions by other major donors including Britain, have forced the UN to make massive spending cuts at a time when its work is more urgent than ever. There are more than 130 armed conflicts raging around the world in 2024 – more than twice as many as 15 years earlier, according to the International Committee of the Red Cross. 

On top of that, there are currently few topics that the five most powerful member states — China, Russia, France, the U.K. and the U.S., known as the P5 because they have permanent positions on the Security Council — can all agree on. In September, with months to go before stepping down, Guterres warned that divisions among the powers in charge were paralyzing the organization and preventing action on everything from Gaza to AI.

Unsurprisingly, this disagreement extends to who should be its next leader. The next secretary general is selected by the 15 members of the U.N. Security Council – five permanent members plus 10 who serve on a rotating basis – before being approved by the General Assembly (that’s all the member states. Do keep up!). Because the five permanent members have a veto, they need to agree on a candidate before a formal vote can be held. By this point in the cycle, such a vote would normally have taken place to allow an orderly transition of power before January. The fact that it hasn’t indicates they are struggling to agree.

The risk is that they end up with a leader no one actively opposes, rather than one with the strong agenda for change that even the U.N.’s strongest supporters agree is needed. One of the highest profile candidates, Michelle Bachelet, the former Chilean president who also served as the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, dropped out of the race in September, reportedly because she scored poorly in one of the informal votes used to narrow in on a consensus candidate.

Journalism is under threat.
Please support The Persistent with a one-time contribution, so we can keep women in the spotlight.
Other amount
Join 9 readers who have tipped

Even with all its current challenges, the U.N. matters. Last year, its World Food Programme assisted 121 million people globally — 54% of them women and girls. The U.N. was responsible for the delicate negotiations to get food trucks into a devastated Gaza. This year, U.N. workers have responded to the Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo and to the deadly flooding in Nepal, among other crises. 

So what are the chances of a woman taking over? Well, there was pressure to elect a woman last time, and it didn't work. This time around, a majority of the current candidates are female, and the frontrunner is reported to be the Costa Rican economist Rebeca Grynspan, though countries can still nominate candidates until the process ends, so it remains an open race. The U.N. tries to rotate the leadership by region and because its most recent leaders have been from Africa, Asia and Europe, the next one is likely (though not certain) to be from the Americas. 

These are the five women in the running for the top job:

Rebeca Grynspan 

The former Costa Rican vice president, an economist by training, is seen as the narrow frontrunner but has struggled to break ahead of the pack, amid reported opposition among the five permanent members (though we don’t know which ones because the results of the polls aren’t made public). Since 2021 she’s served as Secretary-General of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), the first woman to hold that post. 

Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett

The 53-year-old former Guyanese foreign minister has served as her country's permanent representative to the United Nations since 2020. If elected, she’d be the first person from the Caribbean as well as the first woman to hold the job. Born into the Arawak community indigenous to the Caribbean island and coming from one of the regions most vulnerable to global warming, she has said she’d prioritize climate issues and ensure the body remains a force for good. 

Lana Nusseibeh

Nusseibeh, a senior UAE diplomat, was a late entrant to the race and has faced opposition from human rights defenders because of her country’s role in the war in Sudan, which has created one of the world’s worst humanitarian crises. She served as UAE ambassador to the U.N. for more than a decade and led the country's successful campaign for election to the Security Council. 

María Fernanda Espinosa

A former foreign minister and defense minister of Ecuador, Espinosa spent the early years of her career working for conservation organizations and campaigning for biodiversity. She has also held numerous positions within the U.N., including president of the General Assembly. 

—
Claire Cozens is a London-based writer and editor, and a recovering foreign correspondent. She's reported from more than a dozen countries and lived in New Delhi, Beijing, Kathmandu and Paris.

Read more.

❝

Note: As a Bookshop.org affiliate, The Persistent will earn a small commission if you buy a book through a link on this page. Thanks for supporting independent bookstores! 📚